Janesville SEO
← All insights

Hiring an AI search consultant

How should a law firm choose an AI search consultant?

Start with the type of case your partners want more of and the office that would take the call. In the interview, ask the consultant to show you one search for that work. Who did the answer recommend? What did it get right about those firms? Which source would the consultant change first, and who would do the work? A useful proposal puts that answer, the fee, and the first deliverable in writing.

Adam Chubak · Founder, Janesville SEO

Which AI search providers should a law firm consider?

Your shortlist

For a founder-led engagement, Janesville SEO offers a free competitor check and direct access to Adam Chubak, who works with up to 15 ongoing clients. Two agency options with published legal search offerings are Hennessey Digital and Consultwebs. Ask each who would own your account and what they would deliver for your first practice area.

See a Janesville SEO client result

Compare what each proposal buys.

What should a law firm AI search audit include?

An audit should end with a decision your firm can act on. Pick one office and one matter type. Ask for dated answers to both “Which firms handle this?” and “Does our firm handle this?” See who was recommended, what the answer said about each firm, and which pages it cited.

What to take to the partners’ meeting  One example answer, the relevant page on your site or an outside profile, a proposed correction, and the person responsible. If no Google AI Overview appeared, the report should say so.

What drives the cost of AEO or GEO for law firms?

Ask for three prices in writing: the initial audit, the changes you approve, and repeat reporting. The largest difference between two quotes can be who does the editing. A vendor may identify weak practice pages while your current agency charges separately to rewrite and publish them.

A budget question worth asking  “What would we pay through the first recheck for one office and one practice, including anything our current provider must do?” Then price a second office separately. You can see what an initial engagement costs and what would make the bill grow.

How do we compare two proposals for a personal injury practice?

Give both bidders the same brief: “Our plaintiff-side practice wants more commercial truck collision cases in this metro. Show us one search a potential client would make.” Ask each to bring the dated answer, the firms named, and the page they would change first.

Compare the replies on four lines: evidence shown, work included, person doing it, total through the first recheck. If one bid includes attorney interviews and editing and the other ends with a slide deck, the partners can decide who will handle that missing work before signing.

Ask for proof you can inspect.

What experience should a partner ask a consultant to demonstrate?

Ask for a legal client example with dates, a starting count, and a source you can inspect. Then ask, “Which part did you personally handle, and who would do that part for us?” It tells you whether the person in the pitch will also be responsible for delivery.

At Janesville SEO, that person is Adam Chubak, the founder. He has 19 years in digital marketing and has worked with hundreds of law firms. In one client’s case, tracked searches citing the firm in Google AI Overviews grew from 12 to 50. Inspect the figures and dates.

How do we tell whether a reported increase is meaningful?

Ask for the starting count, the size of the search set, the dates, and the cases those searches concerned. In one client’s October-to-October comparison, its site went from being cited in 12 of 576 tracked searches with AI Overviews to 50 of 929. That is about 2.1% to 5.4%. Both the count and its share rose as the tracked set grew.

Next ask whether the gains concern the work your firm wants. A citation for a legal definition and a recommendation to call your firm are worth reporting separately. Intake records are where you can check for a change in qualified consultations. Read the real firm’s case study.

Can a provider guarantee that ChatGPT or Google will recommend us?

No provider controls whether ChatGPT names your firm or Google displays an AI Overview for a particular search. If a proposal promises placement, ask what happens when the next answer names someone else. A commitment you can evaluate specifies the pages to review, the edits the provider will deliver, the evidence you’ll receive, and when the same questions will be checked again. Google’s eligibility guidance.

Clarify the work after the audit.

Can we start without replacing our current SEO provider?

Yes. A second opinion can start with public pages and search answers. Your current agency can keep the website, paid campaigns, and publishing duties. Before anyone edits a page, agree who proposes changes, which attorney approves practice claims, who publishes them, and who verifies the result.

For example, Adam can flag an outdated office in an answer, your agency can update the office page, and your office manager can confirm the intake number. You can request the initial report with just a name, work email, and website. If you’re also considering a switch, see the handoff guide.

How long should it take to see progress?

Ask for two dates in the proposal: when you will receive the first comparison and when you will review the work that actually went live. A useful first review can establish that a wrong phone number was corrected or a practice page was published, even while an AI answer still shows the old information.

Google says recrawling can take days to weeks. That estimate covers the crawl. A recommendation can change later or stay the same. At the next check, repeat the same questions in the same market, save the answers, and record which ones changed. Google’s recrawl guidance.

Ask the questions a proposal can leave out.

Who owns the prompts and reports if we leave?

Get the handoff terms in writing before signing. Ask, “If we leave after the first quarter, can our next provider rerun the questions and check your figures?” Request a sample export with the exact prompts, dates, platform, market, answers, cited links, and record of published changes.

Ask separately who owns custom work, what your firm can keep and reuse, whether the provider’s software is included, and whether export carries a fee or deadline. Have someone at the firm confirm they control the website, analytics, and Search Console accounts. A dashboard login alone won’t answer those questions.

What if AI keeps naming us for matters we decline?

Count a wrong-fit recommendation separately. A firm that wants contested estates may get named for drafting routine wills. Save the exact description, follow the citation, and check how the service is described on the practice page and attorney bio. Have the responsible lawyer confirm the wording before changing it.

At the next review, compare both searches again. Ask intake to tally inquiries the firm declined for this reason. Fewer wrong-fit calls can be a useful outcome even if total mentions stay flat.

What is the difference between a free report and ongoing work?

The free Janesville SEO report answers a first decision: which competitors show up for your work, how your firm is described, and which gap deserves attention first? It is a one-time snapshot. You can discuss the finding with your partners or give it to your existing agency.

Ongoing work makes sense when you want someone to carry the fix through: agree on the priority, update the relevant pages or profiles, and repeat the checks to see what changed. Request your free competitor report or request a 15-minute conversation with Adam.

What would the audit show for your firm?

Request a free competitor report, or talk with Adam about a practice area you want to grow.

Get my free report Request a 15-minute call
Scroll to Top