Janesville SEO
← All insights

AI search visibility for law firms

Why does AI recommend a competing law firm?

Start with a question about a matter your firm wants. Save the answer that recommended your competitor and open its sources. Look for the fact that helped a prospective client choose: an attorney who handles that case, an office near them, or a clear explanation of the next step. Then see whether a stranger could verify the same information about your firm. That comparison gives you a specific place to start.

Adam Chubak · Founder, Janesville SEO

An example from our client work

12 → 50

Google AI Overviews cited one law firm’s pages for 50 tracked U.S. desktop searches in October 2026, up from 12 a year earlier.

Read the client case study

Start with the client’s question.

How can I tell if ChatGPT mentions my law firm?

Run two checks for the same practice and market. First ask “Which firms handle contested estates in Milwaukee?” Then ask “Does [firm name] handle contested estates in Milwaukee?” Start a fresh chat for each. The first tests whether someone could discover your firm. The second tests what a referred client would learn.

Save the wording, date, answer, and links. Mark whether your firm was named, explicitly recommended, or cited as a source. If it was named, copy the description so someone at the firm can judge its tone and accuracy.

What does query fan-out mean for a law firm?

Google describes query fan-out as running related searches to develop an answer. For “Who can help me force a buyout after a partnership dispute?”, possible follow-up topics include minority-owner rights, local litigation counsel, and whether a lawyer has handled a similar dispute. The searcher sees one answer. The exact internal searches behind it usually aren’t visible.

Listen for those follow-ups at intake. Answer the service question on the practice page, document the attorney’s relevant experience in the bio, and link the two where that connection helps the reader. How Google describes query fan-out.

Does it matter whether the person asks for the “best” lawyer?

It can. In a Chicago check, “best” and “top” car accident lawyer searches shared two of three firms. Asking which firm an injured driver should call returned three different names. That gives a partner a reason to test the words a caller actually uses.

Try one broad question and one specific hiring question in separate chats for the same market. Keep both wordings on file. Changing “best lawyer” to “who handles commercial truck crashes?” between reporting periods changes the test itself.

Trace the source before changing a page.

How can a competitor appear when our website ranks well?

A firm can rank for a broad phrase while a competitor is easier to verify for a specific matter. Take a hypothetical search for Madison truck crash counsel. If the answer cites a competitor’s attorney bio, open it and look for trucking experience and the office that handles those calls. Then try to find those same facts from your own injury page. If they’re hard to find, you have a specific gap to fix.

Record the original answer before editing. After the update, repeat that question and check the description and sources. A new citation and a new recommendation are two separate results.

Can AI cite our page and still recommend another firm?

Yes. An AI answer might cite your article to explain a filing deadline and name another lawyer when the reader asks whom to call. Credit your article as a source and the other firm as the recommendation. Keep the words the answer used about each firm.

Follow the link as a prospective client. Can you tell which attorney at your firm handles the problem? Can you reach the right office from the cited page? Those are improvements the firm can make even when the answer continues to recommend someone else.

What if AI names the firm but describes the wrong office or work?

Save the sentence that is wrong, the source link, and the date. Check the cited page against the office and attorney pages your firm controls. If a directory lists a closed office, request a correction there as well. Give one person responsibility for recording the old wording, corrected wording, and date the source changed.

Retest the same location-specific question and call the listed number to verify where it routes. A flattering answer that sends a caller to the wrong office is still an intake problem.

Decide what to change first.

Should each question get a separate page?

Create a separate page when the client has a distinct decision to make and your firm has enough firsthand detail to answer it. “Does the firm represent minority owners?” and “Which attorney handles those disputes?” usually belong together on the partnership disputes page. A detailed, lawyer-reviewed guide to what to bring to a first consultation may deserve its own page.

Keep related follow-up answers together, give each a clear heading, and link to the responsible lawyer. Avoid publishing several versions of one answer with only the city or question wording changed.

What should our developer check if the right page never appears?

Give your developer the exact practice-page URL. Ask them to check its status, the canonical URL Google selected, indexing in Search Console, and whether Google can show a snippet. Then confirm the office, attorney, and service are readable on the page and reachable through an internal link.

For ChatGPT Search, check whether the site allows OAI-SearchBot. Ask for the inspection result and a specific fix if something is blocked. Passing the checks establishes technical eligibility. Google’s technical requirements · OpenAI’s search guidance.

Check whether the change helped.

How do we measure visibility when answers vary?

Keep the questions, market, and platform fixed. Save every dated answer and its cited URLs. Report appearances as a count out of completed answers on that platform. Record missing Google AI Overviews and failed checks separately. For sentiment, retain the wording about each named firm so someone can review how it was portrayed.

In our November 2026 provider search, consumer ChatGPT and Google’s Overview shared several names, while an OpenAI API search returned a different first pair. Keep a separate history for each surface. A switch between them can look like a gain or loss even when your site hasn’t changed.

Which results matter to a managing partner?

Put three lines on the partner scorecard for each practice you want to grow. Discovery: How often did the answer recommend your firm for the right work? Accuracy: Did it identify the right office, attorney, and service? Intake: How many qualified consultations and signed matters did your intake team record, and how many clients said an AI search helped them find you?

Show counts alongside rates and keep unattributed inquiries in their own line. A consultation can have several touchpoints. An increase in direct traffic alone won’t tell you how many clients came from AI. See how one firm’s search results were measured.

See which firms appear in your market.

Get a free, one-time comparison for your firm. Start with your website, name, and work email.

Get my free report Request a 15-minute call
Scroll to Top